All posts
Relocation

Moving to St. Augustine, FL: What to Know Before You Buy

What relocation buyers should know about St. Augustine: home prices, historic district rules, flood and insurance checks, Florida's new homestead rules, and how to get connected with a local agent.

Nicole Mickle

Nicole Mickle

Realtor, Olympus Executive Realty

Moving to St. Augustine, Florida: Your Guide to a Smooth Transition

The short answer

St. Augustine is the county seat of St. Johns County on Florida's Atlantic coast, about an hour south of Jacksonville and two hours from Orlando. The median sale price in St. Augustine was $507,650 in September 2026, down about 6% from a year earlier, with homes averaging 74 days on market, according to Houzeo's analysis of MLS data. Expect flood questions near the water and design review for older homes in the historic districts.

I'm Nicole Mickle, a Central Florida relocation and new construction specialist. I've worked in Florida real estate since 1996, including 23 years running a mobile closing company, and I've been a licensed Realtor since 2012. St. Augustine isn't my home market, but the questions relocation buyers miss there are the same ones I see in Orlando. This guide covers them, and how to find the right agent on the ground.

How much does a home cost in St. Augustine?

St. Augustine had a median sale price of $507,650 in September 2026, down about 6% from September 2025, according to Houzeo's analysis of Stellar MLS and Northeast Florida MLS data. Homes averaged 74 days on market.

That number covers the city only. A St. Augustine mailing address reaches well beyond city limits, including St. Augustine Beach, Vilano Beach, and newer communities toward World Golf Village and the northwest part of St. Johns County. Prices, HOA fees, and flood exposure vary widely across them, so ask which area a figure describes before you budget around it.

Where is St. Augustine, and how far is it from Orlando?

St. Augustine sits on the Atlantic coast in St. Johns County, about 40 miles south of downtown Jacksonville. Orlando is roughly 105 miles away, usually an hour and 45 minutes to two hours via I-95 and I-4. Jacksonville International Airport is 50 minutes to an hour north. Founded in 1565, St. Augustine is the oldest continuously occupied European-founded city in the continental United States.

Florida relocation markets at a glance
CityCountyMedian sale priceDrive to OrlandoNearest major airport
Naples (city limits)Collier$2.25 million (Sept. 2026)3.5 to 4 hoursSouthwest Florida International (RSW), 30 to 40 minutes
Bonita SpringsLee$510,000 (Oct. 2026)About 3.5 hoursSouthwest Florida International (RSW), about 20 minutes
LakelandPolk$303,500 (Oct. 2026)About 1 hourTampa International (TPA), 45 to 60 minutes
OcalaMarion$265,819 (Oct. 2026)About 1.5 hoursGainesville Regional (GNV), about 45 minutes
St. AugustineSt. Johns$507,650 (Sept. 2026)1.75 to 2 hoursJacksonville International (JAX), 50 to 60 minutes

Median sale prices above are for each city's limits, from Houzeo's analysis of MLS data for the month shown. Drive times are typical and vary with traffic.

What should I know about flooding and insurance in St. Augustine?

In St. Augustine, flood risk belongs in your budget from day one. Parts of the historic downtown and low-lying neighborhoods flooded during Hurricanes Matthew in 2016 and Irma in 2017, and strong nor'easters can push water into streets as well. Check the FEMA flood zone and elevation certificate, and get homeowners and flood insurance quotes during your inspection period.

Since October 1, 2025, Florida sellers have had to disclose flood damage that happened while they owned the home, plus any help they received to repair it, whether or not they filed a claim, according to Florida Realtors. When I ran closings, a late insurance quote was one of the most common reasons an out-of-state buyer's budget fell apart in the final week.

What changes when you buy in a St. Augustine historic district?

Exterior changes to homes in St. Augustine's historic districts generally need approval from the city's Historic Architectural Review Board before work begins. That can include windows, roofing, porches, fences, and additions. Before you buy an older home planning to update it, ask the city what review your plans would need and budget extra time for it.

What most relocation buyers get wrong: Florida's new homestead rules

Florida voters approved Amendment 3 on November 3, 2026. Starting with the 2027 tax roll, the homestead exemption on non-school property taxes rises to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028. People who were not Florida residents by December 31, 2026 start with a smaller exemption and qualify for the larger one in their fifth year of homestead, according to the Florida Department of Revenue.

If you move to St. Augustine in 2027 or later, the seller's tax bill is a poor guide to yours. Ask for an estimate based on your purchase price and residency date, and confirm it with the St. Johns County Property Appraiser, since the state is still issuing guidance. Buying a second home instead? Amendment 3 lowers the annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property from 10% to 5% for non-school taxes, starting in 2027.

How do I find a good real estate agent in St. Augustine?

Look for an agent who sells regularly in the part of St. Augustine you want, whether that's downtown, the beaches, or the newer communities inland. They should be able to explain flood zones, historic review, and HOA or CDD fees without guessing, and respond quickly while you're deciding from out of state.

I don't sell homes in St. Augustine, but I can connect you with a local agent there and help you think through the closing-side questions along the way: title, insurance timing, and what your tax bill will actually look like.

Comparing more than one Florida city? I also have relocation guides for Naples, Bonita Springs, Lakeland, and Ocala. If Central Florida is still in the running, start with my Orlando relocation guide or the neighborhood quiz.

Planning a move to St. Augustine?

Tell me where you're headed and what matters most to you, and I'll make the introduction. Start the conversation.

Frequently Asked

Questions, answered

How far is St. Augustine from Orlando and Jacksonville?

St. Augustine is about 105 miles from Orlando, usually an hour and 45 minutes to two hours via I-95 and I-4. Downtown Jacksonville is about 40 miles north, and Jacksonville International Airport is 50 minutes to an hour away, depending on traffic.

Is St. Augustine expensive?

St. Augustine had a median sale price of $507,650 in September 2026, according to Houzeo's analysis of MLS data. That figure covers city limits only. Beachfront areas and newer master-planned communities elsewhere in St. Johns County can price higher, so compare specific neighborhoods rather than one citywide number.

Can I renovate a historic home in St. Augustine?

Usually, but exterior changes in the city's historic districts generally need approval from the Historic Architectural Review Board first. That can cover windows, roofs, porches, fences, and additions. Ask the City of St. Augustine what review your plans would need before you buy.

Do new Florida residents get the full homestead exemption?

Not right away. Under Amendment 3, approved in November 2026, people who were not Florida residents by December 31, 2026 start with a smaller homestead exemption and qualify for the larger one in their fifth year of homestead. Confirm the details with the St. Johns County Property Appraiser.