All posts
Orlando Real Estate

How to Choose a Real Estate Agent in Orlando: 6 Things to Look For

How to choose a buyer's agent in Orlando, from local and builder knowledge to relocation experience, honest advice, and a clear written agreement.

Nicole Mickle

Nicole Mickle

Realtor, Olympus Executive Realty

How to Choose Your Orlando Agent cover graphic with an Orlando map, house keys, and Florida keychains

TL;DR

  • Local knowledge comes first: choose an agent who knows the neighborhoods and builders you're considering, not just the Orlando market in general.
  • Relocating? Ask how they work remotely: live video tours, digital signing, and title companies that can close by mail make a long-distance purchase much easier.
  • Look for honest advice: a good agent will raise insurance, HOA and CDD fees, flood zones, and appraisal risk before you make an offer.
  • Get the terms in writing: since August 2024, buyers working with a REALTOR sign a written agreement before touring that spells out services and pay.

The right agent can save you months of searching and thousands of dollars, especially when you're moving from out of state or buying new construction. I'm Nicole Mickle, a Central Florida relocation and new construction specialist with 30 years in the industry. I ran a mobile closing company for 23 years and have been a licensed Realtor since 2012, so I've seen how much a buyer's agent affects what happens at the closing table. Here's what to look for when you choose an agent to help you buy in the Orlando area.

What makes a good buyer's agent in Orlando?

A good buyer's agent in Orlando knows the specific neighborhoods and builders you're considering, has helped buyers relocate from out of state, listens closely to how you want to live, tells you about costs and risks before you commit, has strong relationships with lenders, inspectors, insurance agents, and title companies, and explains in writing how they'll be paid.

What to look for in a buyer's agent
What to look forWhy it mattersHow to check
Local and builder knowledgeOrlando communities vary widelyAsk where they have helped buyers purchase in the past year
Relocation experienceBuying from out of state needs a remote planAsk about video tours and remote closings
Good listeningThe right home may not match your first searchNotice whether they ask how you want to live
Honest adviceInsurance and fees change your monthly costAsk what risks they see before you offer
Strong connectionsProblems near closing need quick fixesAsk who they recommend and why
Clear termsYou should know how they are paidRead the written buyer agreement before touring

1. Do they know the areas and builders you're considering?

Orlando is a collection of very different communities, from established neighborhoods near downtown to master-planned areas like Lake Nona and Horizon West. Ask which communities the agent has helped buyers purchase in over the past year and what they'd recommend for your budget, commute, and lifestyle. If you're considering new construction, ask which builders they know well. The salesperson in a builder's model home represents the builder, and most builders require your agent to register you on your first visit, so bring your agent from the start. My post on purchasing a new construction home explains how that process works.

2. Have they helped buyers relocate from out of state?

Buying from another state takes a different approach. Ask whether the agent offers live video tours, how they check the things a camera can miss, like road noise and drainage, and whether they work with title companies that can close remotely or by mail. Ask how they'll coordinate inspections and walk-throughs if you can't be there. My guide to buying a house in Florida walks through each step, and my moving to Florida checklist covers the rest of the move.

3. Do they listen to how you want to live?

The best agents hear what you don't say. I once worked with a buyer who was set on new construction. After listening to how she wanted to spend her time, I asked if we could take a short detour to an established neighborhood a few miles away. It fit everything she described, and she bought there. A good agent asks about your commute, how much yard you want to maintain, how you feel about HOA rules, and what you want nearby, then shows you options you may not have known existed.

4. Will they tell you the hard truths?

Be cautious of an agent who only tells you what you want to hear. In Central Florida, a good agent will raise the issues that affect your monthly cost and your long-term plans before you write an offer:

  • Insurance: roof age, construction type, and location all affect your premium. Get real quotes during your inspection period.
  • HOA and CDD fees: many newer communities carry both. My guide to HOA and CDD fees explains what to ask.
  • Flood zones and drainage: ask whether the home is in a flood zone and what coverage costs.
  • Appraisal risk: in a competitive situation, ask what happens if the appraisal comes in below your offer.

5. Are they well connected?

A real estate purchase involves lenders, inspectors, insurance agents, appraisers, title companies, and sometimes builders and contractors. An agent with good relationships can help solve problems quickly when something comes up close to closing. Ask who they recommend and why, and remember that you're always free to choose your own providers.

6. How will they be paid?

Since August 17, 2024, buyers working with an agent who is a REALTOR must sign a written agreement before touring homes. The agreement spells out the services the agent will provide and how they'll be paid (National Association of REALTORS). Commissions are negotiable. Ask what happens if a seller or builder won't cover the fee, how long the agreement lasts, and how either of you can end it. My post on buyer agents vs. seller agents explains the different types of representation in Florida.

Selling, too?

If you're also selling a home, the questions are a little different. My post on questions to ask before you hire a listing agent covers pricing, marketing, and the listing agreement.

Ready to start your search?

The best way to know whether an agent is the right fit is a conversation about your timeline, budget, and must-haves. Reach out to me, and I'll explain how I work with relocation and new construction buyers before you sign anything.

Frequently Asked

Questions, answered

How do I choose a real estate agent in Orlando?

Look for an agent who knows the specific neighborhoods and builders you are considering, has helped buyers relocate from out of state, gives honest advice about insurance and fees, and explains in writing how they will be paid.

Do I need my own agent to buy new construction?

In most cases, yes. The salesperson in a builder's model home represents the builder. Most builders require your agent to register you on your first visit, so bring your agent from the start.

Can I buy a home in Orlando without being there in person?

Yes. Many relocation buyers tour homes by live video and close remotely or by mail through a Florida title company. Ask your agent how they check things a camera can miss, like road noise and drainage.

Do I have to sign an agreement with a buyer's agent?

If your agent is a REALTOR, yes. Since August 2024, buyers sign a written agreement before touring homes that explains the agent's services and how they will be paid. Commissions are negotiable.