01
Entry
$350K - $475K
Townhomes, older resale single-family homes, and smaller homes in established neighborhoods. 3 bed, 1,200-1,600 sq ft.
Homes for Sale inLake Mary, FL
Seminole County's polished suburban hub with top-rated schools
Top SchoolsCorporate HubUpscaleFamily-Oriented
$350K - $1M+
Price Range
25-30 minutes
Downtown
35-40 minutes
Airport
40-55 minutes
Disney
Looking for homes for sale in Lake Mary, FL? You are looking at Seminole County's polished suburban hub, home to one of the top-rated school districts in Florida and corporate headquarters like AAA. Weekends center on Colonial TownPark with its Saturday farmers market, while the Cross Seminole and Seminole Wekiva Trails make it easy to bike or walk without ever hitting a major road. After 30 years in this market, here is everything you need to know before you buy.
“Lake Mary residents enjoy a well-manicured suburban lifestyle with strong community infrastructure.”
The Lifestyle
Weekday mornings mean a quick I-4 commute to downtown Orlando or a walk to one of the area's many corporate offices. Weekends center on Colonial TownPark – Saturday farmers market, brunch at Boca, or the annual Lake Mary-Heathrow Festival of the Arts. The extensive trail system makes it easy to bike or walk without ever hitting a major road.
The Highlights
- 01
Seminole County Schools ranked #3 best district in Florida
- 02
Colonial TownPark with dining, shopping, and weekly farmers market
- 03
Corporate offices including AAA national headquarters
- 04
Cross Seminole Trail and Seminole Wekiva Trail for biking and walking
Best For
- Families prioritizing top-rated public schools (Seminole County district)
- Corporate professionals working at Lake Mary/Heathrow office parks
- Buyers seeking upscale suburban living with walkable shopping and dining
- Active adults who value biking and walking trails
Not Ideal For
- Buyers on a tight budget under $350K
- Those seeking a quirky, artsy, or urban-feeling neighborhood
- Commuters to south Orlando or the attractions corridor (long drive)
Price Points
$350K - $1M+
What it costs to live in Lake Mary, from entry-level to premium.
02
Mid-Range
$475K - $700K
Newer single-family homes in communities like Stoneridge (Taylor Morrison) and established neighborhoods like Timacuan. 3-4 bed, 1,800-2,500 sq ft.
03
Premium
$700K - $1M+
Heathrow gated community, lakefront properties, and luxury new construction. 4-5 bed, 2,500-4,000+ sq ft.
New Construction
New Construction Homes in Lake Mary
Lake Mary is largely built out with limited new construction, mostly custom infill. The established neighborhoods and strong school demand keep resale values high, but raw land for new communities is scarce.
Builders
David Weekley HomesHolland Builders Co.
Schools
Education in Lake Mary
Heathrow Elementary
(A-rated, Niche)
- Lake Mary Elementary
- Greenwood Lakes Middle
Lake Mary High School
(A-rated, Niche)
Lake Mary Preparatory School
(private, PreK-12)
Dining
Where to eat
FishBones
seafood, steaks, and sushi
Boca
upscale American, Colonial TownPark
Ruth's Chris Steak House
classic steakhouse
Pisco Peruvian Gastrobar
Peruvian, craft cocktails
Local Tips
Nicole's Lake Mary notes
Nicole Mickle
30 years in Orlando
01
The Lake Mary Farmers Market runs every Saturday at Central Park – fresh produce, baked goods, and local vendors
02
I-4 congestion between Lake Mary and downtown is worst 7-9:30 AM southbound – the SunRail commuter train from the Lake Mary station is a real alternative
03
Colonial TownPark hosts WineART Wednesday on the first Wednesday of each month with food trucks and live music
04
The Heathrow community just south of Lake Mary proper has some of the highest-rated school zones and most established landscaping in the area
Frequently Asked
Lake Mary home-buying FAQ
How much do homes for sale in Lake Mary, FL cost?
Homes run from about $350K for townhomes and older resale single-family homes up to $1M+ for Heathrow gated properties, lakefront homes, and luxury new construction. Most newer single-family homes fall in the $475K to $700K range.
Is Lake Mary a good area for new construction?
New construction is limited. Lake Mary is largely built out, so most new builds are custom infill from builders like David Weekley Homes and Holland Builders Co. Strong school demand keeps resale values high, but raw land for new communities is scarce.
What is it like living in Lake Mary, Orlando?
Lake Mary is a polished suburban hub with top-rated Seminole County schools, corporate offices like AAA, walkable shopping and dining at Colonial TownPark, a Saturday farmers market, and an extensive trail system for biking and walking.
How far is Lake Mary from downtown Orlando and Disney?
Lake Mary is about 25 to 30 minutes from downtown Orlando, 35 to 40 minutes from Orlando International Airport, and 40 to 55 minutes from Disney.
Interested in Lake Mary?
I can tell you what it's really like to live here, what the market looks like right now, and whether it's the right fit for your lifestyle.